Skip to content
Monday, November 9, 2026
London Play Review

Which Players Feature in Troy's Premier League Weekly Best XI?

In the wake of each round of English top-flight games this season, Well-known football pundit Troy Deeney selects his team and gaffer of the week.

Here are this week's selections. What are your thoughts? Share your views.

Between the Sticks

Jordan Pickford (Everton): A crucial play in Everton's comprehensive win against Chelsea came from his superb denial to keep out Enzo Fernandez. He has delivered pretty big in those situations for Everton this season and, hopefully, he maintains this form for the national team at the upcoming World Cup. Just last week, he committed a costly error against Arsenal but has bounced back again to produce for the Toffees.

The Backline

Neco Williams (Nottingham Forest): It proved to be a enormous crunch game for Forest when they visited Tottenham, with Premier League status at stake for each team. And Williams produced a tremendous performance to aid his side get a crucial victory in the relegation fight. He provided two assists, delivering when it mattered most.

Matty Cash (Aston Villa): In my view, West Ham provided a whole lot of danger in attack but Cash stood firm and kept things together for Villa. He succeeded in just keep ticking over. He offered a lot in an attacking sense and was also able to snuff out all the Hammers offered in the final third.

James Tarkowski (Everton): It was another solid display from the Toffees defender. He exhibited his composure and authority, and consistently positionally perfect. He produced those tackles when needed and, significantly, served as a calming influence in their backline. How Chelsea must wish for a central defender with such fortitude, particularly in light of the unconvincing defending they have exhibited at times.

Engine Room

Chris Rigg (Sunderland): It amounted to a steady performance from Rigg in a historic Tyne-Wear derby. He didn't produce anything exceptional against Newcastle but he did everything exceptionally competently. With Rigg, you are aware of exactly what to expect from him.

James Garner (Everton): He easily could have relaxed after receiving a call-up to the Three Lions team this week. But instead, he got on with it and put in a excellent display. It was a exquisite pass from him to Beto for his team's first goal. Having played with him at Watford, I am aware he's synonymous with non-stop running and strong challenges. He has got it all and I trust he does well for England to force his way into that World Cup final roster.

John McGinn (Aston Villa): He's their captain, leader and key figure. It's amounted to a pair of huge performances in the space of a week from him. Villa are a good side. But McGinn elevates them to a great one. If they are going to secure the top five and challenge for the Europa League title, they will need him to continue performing at these heights.

Harry Wilson (Fulham): He has developed a habit of netting important goals and he did that once more in the latest round. I wonder how they can possibly replace him if he opts to depart. They won't pay £60m on a player with his qualities. They desperately want him to sign a renewal as he is a massively important component of that Fulham set-up.

The Forwards

Bruno Fernandes (Manchester United): It seems as though the Portuguese playmaker is becoming a permanent fixture in the team of the week. You simply have to include him once again following a further goal, and also being involved in the James Hill own goal. How long will United remain average and retain his services before he feels it is time to depart the club?

Beto (Everton): On this occasion, we have a pair of strikers who are at vastly contrasting stages in their career. I am not sure Beto is a long-term solution for the Merseyside club's scoring woes, but boss David Moyes is getting the best out of him currently. It is impressive considering how poor he was in the initial months.

Danny Welbeck (Brighton): He was overlooked by the England manager again for the England squad, at a time when they could use cover to skipper Harry Kane. But Welbeck continued to produce for the Seagulls with a double, to overcome reigning champions Liverpool, and take his total to 12 goals for the campaign.

The Dugout Doyen

David Moyes (Everton): The game between Everton and Chelsea was a textbook embodiment of traditional against modern. Blues boss Liam Rosenior is attempting to establish himself at the start of his coaching journey but Moyes formulated a flawless gameplan to secure a convincing result. The Toffees were more assertive and more robust in all departments of the game and it was a massive win for them.

Do you agree with Deeney's picks? Which players would make up your Team of the Week? Share your thoughts.

BW
About the author

Brittany West

A seasoned arts critic with a passion for London's vibrant theatre scene.

London Play Review

Type to search articles.